Hello, All!

I am trying to understand why jamnntpd/smapinntpd will write my from address 2:5015/46 in reverse order like this <[email protected].2>. Is it a bug or a feature?
I guess it is a feature but then what kind of issue it tries to solve?

Below is the snippet from nntpserv.c which does it

if(sscanf(fromaddr,"%u:%u/%u.%u", &zone, &net, &node, &point)==4)
sprintf(fromaddr,"%u@%u.%u.%u", point, node, net, zone);

Best Regards, Nil
--- GoldED+/LNX 1.1.5-b20240306
* Origin: ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check important info. (2:5015/46)

Hello, Nil Alexandrov.
On 14/09/2025 6.21 you wrote:

Hello, All! I am trying to understand why
jamnntpd/smapinntpd will write my from address
2:5015/46 in reverse order like this
<[email protected].2>. Is it a bug or a feature? I guess
it is a feature but then what kind of issue it
tries to solve?

It is a feature. Some nntp clients dont like chars : and / in the email address. That is the way to show ftn address in email-like format.



--
'Tommi

--- FastEcho/2 1.46.1 Revival
* Origin: nntp://rbb.fidonet.fi - Finland (2:221/360.0)

Hello, Tommi!

Sunday September 14 2025 10:06, from Tommi Koivula -> Nil Alexandrov:

I am trying to understand why
jamnntpd/smapinntpd will write my from address
2:5015/46 in reverse order like this
<[email protected].2>. Is it a bug or a feature? I guess
it is a feature but then what kind of issue it
tries to solve?

It is a feature. Some nntp clients dont like chars : and / in the
email address. That is the way to show ftn address in email-like
format.

I understand that part but still why using a point number as a username before the @ symbol? Why writing the FTN address in reverse order? Why not follow say http://ftsc.org/docs/frl-1002.001 [email protected] ?

Also, there is a bug with the X-SMAPI-From field, which I will try to investigate later
X-SMAPI-From: Dmitry Protasoff <0:0/0.0>
X-SMAPI-To: Nil A <2:5001/100.1>

Best Regards, Nil
--- GoldED+/LNX 1.1.5-b20240306
* Origin: ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check important info. (2:5015/46)

Hey Nil!

On Sun, Sep 14 2025 07:17:14 -0500, you wrote:

I understand that part but still why using a point number as a
username before the @ symbol? Why writing the FTN address in reverse
order? Why not follow say http://ftsc.org/docs/frl-1002.001 [email protected] ?

I agree here. If there were to be any way to email a person through some sort of gateway or other, it should probably follow this method. Although, just to be fair here, the above is also in reverse order, it just also includes a user name and gateway domain. > Also, there is a bug with the X-SMAPI-From field, which I will try

to investigate later
X-SMAPI-From: Dmitry Protasoff <0:0/0.0> > X-SMAPI-To: Nil A <2:5001/100.1>

I've noticed this as well in the past and never really thought anything of it, until you brought it up.

Regards,
Nick

... Sarcasm, because beating people up is illegal.
--- Mozilla Thunderbird
* Origin: The Pharcyde ~ telnet://bbs.pharcyde.org (Wisconsin) (1:154/10)

Hello, Nick!

Sunday September 14 2025 08:56, from Nick Boel -> Nil Alexandrov:

I agree here. If there were to be any way to email a person through
some sort of gateway or other, it should probably follow this method.

I think the right solution would be to specify the *gateway.domain* in the config and that should construct the from address like [email protected]. This is not a big patch I might be able to provide.

bug with the X-SMAPI-From field, which I will try

to investigate later
X-SMAPI-From: Dmitry Protasoff <0:0/0.0> > X-SMAPI-To: Nil A
<2:5001/100.1>

I've noticed this as well in the past and never really thought
anything of it, until you brought it up.

I can find what is wrong there and fix but the first thing I would like to do is to sync all the branches of jamnntpd/smapinntpd. Check this out what..

% git remote -v
axxisd https://github.com/axxisd/smapinntpd (fetch)
axxisd https://github.com/axxisd/smapinntpd (push)
jam_axxisd https://github.com/axxisd/jamnntpd (fetch)
jam_axxisd https://github.com/axxisd/jamnntpd (push)
jam_cnb https://github.com/cnb/jamnntpd.git (fetch)
jam_cnb https://github.com/cnb/jamnntpd.git (push)
jam_ftnapps https://github.com/ftnapps/jamnntpd.git (fetch)
jam_ftnapps https://github.com/ftnapps/jamnntpd.git (push)
origin https://github.com/ftnapps/smapinntpd.git (fetch)
origin https://github.com/ftnapps/smapinntpd.git (push)

Best Regards, Nil
--- GoldED+/LNX 1.1.5-b20240306
* Origin: ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check important info. (2:5015/46)

Hey Nil!

On Sun, 14 Sep 2025 17:55:50 +0300, you wrote:

I think the right solution would be to specify the *gateway.domain* in
the config and that should construct the from address like [email protected]. This is not a big patch I
might be able to provide.

Agreed and that would be awesome?

I can find what is wrong there and fix but the first thing I would like
to do is to sync all the branches of jamnntpd/smapinntpd. Check this out what..

% git remote -v
axxisd https://github.com/axxisd/smapinntpd (fetch)
axxisd https://github.com/axxisd/smapinntpd (push)
jam_axxisd https://github.com/axxisd/jamnntpd (fetch)
jam_axxisd https://github.com/axxisd/jamnntpd (push)

The above are mine, and have recently been updated to compile on the latest gcc 15.2.1, and smapinntpd includes/installs smapi with part of the make process so you don't have to go and install it separately yourself.

I'm unsure as to if either of them compile or work on Windows, though.

jam_cnb https://github.com/cnb/jamnntpd.git (fetch)
jam_cnb https://github.com/cnb/jamnntpd.git (push)

This is Carlos Navarro's fork, which I believe he used on Windows. I haven't actually heard from him in some time, though. Maybe he is still able to be contacted through Fidonet?

jam_ftnapps https://github.com/ftnapps/jamnntpd.git (fetch)
jam_ftnapps https://github.com/ftnapps/jamnntpd.git (push)
origin https://github.com/ftnapps/smapinntpd.git (fetch)
origin https://github.com/ftnapps/smapinntpd.git (push)

These are the original repos by RJ Clay. I believe he took what was on sourceforge at the time (1.0 by Billings), changed up a few things, changing versions from 1.1 to 1.2, and then put it on github as v1.3. Nobody has access to these, because the maintainer (RJ) has passed away. So both Carlos and myself forked from this version. I don't think Carlos has done much with it after initially fixing some very annoying outstanding bugs.

For the record, my repositories have everything Carlos has done and more. I'm unsure as to why we didn't work together to begin with, but that was awhile ago now.

Is there anything else we can do? I'm not much of a github wizard or anything so I would gladly take suggestions.

Regards,
Nick

... Sarcasm: because beating people up is illegal.
--- GoldED+/LNX 1.1.5-b20250409
* Origin: _thePharcyde telnet://bbs.pharcyde.org (Wisconsin) (1:154/10)

Nil Alexandrov wrote:

Also, there is a bug with the X-SMAPI-From field, which I will try
to investigate later
X-SMAPI-From: Dmitry Protasoff <0:0/0.0>
X-SMAPI-To: Nil A <2:5001/100.1>

I have 'fixed' this in the past, removed the ftn address part. :) I
think these X-SMAPI-* fields are only for information.. ?

Path: SmapiNNTPd!not-for-mail
From: Nil Alexandrov <[email protected].2>
To: Tommi Koivula
X-Comment-To: Tommi Koivula
Newsgroups: jamnntpd
Subject: Fromaddr question
Date: Sun, 14 Sep 2025 07:17:14 +0300
Message-ID: <351$jamnntpd@SmapiNNTPd>
References: <350$jamnntpd@SmapiNNTPd>
X-SMAPI-From: Nil Alexandrov
X-SMAPI-To: Tommi Koivula
X-SMAPI-DateWritten: 14 Sep 25 10:17:14
X-SMAPI-DateArrived: 14 Sep 25 10:21:56
X-SMAPI-Control: @REPLY: 2:221/360.0 68c6698a
X-SMAPI-Control: @MSGID: 2:5015/46 68c66cf5

'Tommi

---
* Origin: smapinntpd/lnx (2:221/1.0)